Emotional Vs. Physical Hunger: 4 Ways to Tell the Difference

It’s not easy to know the difference between physical and emotional hunger. When you have a craving for something sweet and gooey like a chocolate chip cookie or a cinnamon roll it could be:

A) Your stomach’s way of gently reminding you that it’s time to refuel (carb cravings often come from being overly hungry!).


B) A signal that you are bored and in need of a distraction.

How can you tell? These two hunger pangs often feel exactly the same as I explain in detail in my new book 50 More Ways to Soothe Yourself Without Food (Pre-order bonuses are still available). It is like when the eye doctor asks you which image is clearer, “A” or “B” and they look exactly the same.

Here are four questions to ask yourself when you need to spot the difference between an emotional tug for comfort and a genuine need for nourishment. The good news is that with some practice, you can become an expert at decoding the meaning behind your cravings.

1) Satisfaction vs. Relief

Do I want to eat for energy to fuel my body to make it through the day or am I looking for relief or a sense of safety/security?

Test: Place your hand on the part of your body that needs attention. Does it go to your stomach because it is rumbling? Or, does it go to your brain that feels dull and bored?

Fix: Aim to satisfy the part of your body that your hand rests on. If your brain is bored, give it some mentally stimulating material. If your hand traveled to your shoulders, lift and release your shoulders five times to relax your muscles. If it lands on your stomach, mindfully choose a nourishing food.

2) Emotional vs. Physical Hunger

Am I eating in response to physical hunger (rumbling stomach, low energy, etc.) or am I feeling scared, frustrated, overwhelmed or happy?

Test: Ask yourself, “How physically hungry am I on a scale from 1-10 (1=starving, 5=satiated 10=stuffed)?” If you are a 1-5, it’s likely that you do need something to eat. If so, that is okay. If you answer 6-10, it’s likely that food isn’t going to help a bit.

Fix: Try eating a Mandarin orange. They are a great food to help curb emotional eating and to de-stress. It is easy to peel and the segments are perfectly portioned to mindfully eat one at a time. The sweet flavor is satisfying and research has shown that citrus aromas can be calming. Also, a Mandarin orange gives a little boost of vitamin C, just what you need when stressed or emotional.

3) Nutritious vs. Palatable

Am I choosing nutritious rich foods or sugary, fatty salty foods?

Test: A truly hungry person, will eat a large range of foods that will quickly quiet a rumbling stomach. Someone with an emotionally driven craving often only craves a specific type of food or taste — not just chocolate, but chocolate with caramel. If only a salty snack will do, it’s likely that this is an urge for comfort.

Fix: It’s important to keep good tasting, healthy snacks handy. Often, people keep diet foods around that are bland and don’t taste good. Kick up the taste of vegetables with hummus, sprinkle yogurt with some nuts, drizzle chocolate on berries, add a dash of spice to your vegetable soup, etc.

4) Lifelong vs. Transient

Am I building a healthy relationship with food vs. anxiety, guilt or fear.

Test: Before you eat, ask yourself how you will likely feel a minute after you finish this bite. If a negative emotion springs to mind, take a pause. Too often we wait until after we eat to check in with the emotional impact of what we consume.

Fix: Mindful eating can help you build a healthy and balanced relationship with food. Use the 5 S’s of Mindful Eating no matter what you are eating 1) Sit down 2) Slowly Chew 3) Sense—taste, smell, listen 4) Savor-enjoy 5) Smile (pause before taking another bite). Remember it’s okay to eat the foods you love, as long as you do it mindfully!

To learn more truths and actionable tips for coping with comfort eating, see my new book, 50 More Ways to Soothe Yourself Without Food. I have some amazing pre-order bonuses available right now.

Leave A Comment